The 503A bulks list, explained
Every argument about compounded peptides comes back to one short list in the Code of Federal Regulations. Here is what it is, how something gets on it, and what being on it does and does not mean.
A pharmacy that compounds a drug for an individual patient works under section 503A of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. Section 503A exempts that pharmacy from three things a drug maker must do: get FDA approval (section 505), carry full directions for use on the label (section 502(f)(1)), and follow current good manufacturing practice (section 501(a)(2)(B)). In exchange, the pharmacy has to meet conditions. One of them is about the raw ingredient, the "bulk drug substance".
Three ways an ingredient qualifies
Under section 503A(b)(1)(A)(i), a bulk drug substance may be used if it:
- meets an applicable United States Pharmacopeia or National Formulary monograph, if one exists, and the USP chapter on compounding; or
- is a component of an FDA-approved drug, if no monograph exists; or
- appears on a list FDA develops by regulation: the 503A bulks list.
Most peptides discussed online have no USP monograph and are not part of any approved drug. For them, the third route is the only one. That is why the list matters so much to the peptide debate. Approved peptide drugs such as semaglutide or tesamorelin take the second route, which brings its own limits on copying approved products (see GLP-1 compounding policy).
How FDA decides
FDA set the rules in a final rule published on 19 February 2019 (84 FR 4696). It evaluates four criteria and balances them substance by substance:
| # | Criterion | The question in practice |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Physical and chemical characterization | Is the substance well defined, with known identity, impurities and stability? |
| 2 | Safety issues | What is known about harm from compounded products containing it? |
| 3 | Evidence of effectiveness | Is there evidence it works, or does not, for the uses proposed? |
| 4 | Historical use in compounding | How long and how widely has it been used, and is it in the peer-reviewed literature? |
The 2019 rule placed six substances on the list, all non-peptides and most for topical use only, and declined four. A proposed rule in September 2019 would add five more and decline 26. The list grows slowly because every addition needs its own rulemaking.
The interim categories
Because the list is incomplete, FDA runs an interim policy while it works through nominations. The current guidance was finalised on 7 January 2025 (90 FR 1136), replacing a 2017 version. It sorts nominated substances into three categories:
| Category | FDA label | Practical effect | Peptides in it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Category 1 | Under evaluation | FDA does not generally intend to act against compounding from these while it decides, if other conditions are met. | GHK-Cu (except injectable routes); vasoactive intestinal peptide |
| Category 2 | Raise significant safety risks | Pharmacies should not compound from these. | Kisspeptin-10 (503A). Ibutamoren, a non-peptide, is also listed. |
| Category 3 | Nominated without adequate support | Not considered until a nominator supplies enough information. | Various |
Substances that were in Category 2 but whose nominations were withdrawn are listed separately by FDA. They are in none of the three categories. The Category 2 page goes through them one by one.
What being on the list does, in FDA's words
At the July 2026 committee meeting, Matthew Lash, acting director of FDA's Office of Compounding Quality and Compliance, set out what follows when a substance is placed on the 503A list. His slide said the compounded product "is not FDA approved"; that a 503A product "is not required to have a label to inform patients and providers how to use it"; that it is not required to comply with good manufacturing practice, though the ban on insanitary conditions still applies; that 503A compounders "are not required to report adverse events" to FDA; and that, unless the listing says otherwise, the substance "can be compounded for any use or via any route of administration".
The last point is the one most often missed. FDA reviews a substance for specific proposed uses. BPC-157 was evaluated for ulcerative colitis, MOTS-c for obesity and osteoporosis. A listing without limits would not be tied to those uses.
Why the salt form matters
Russell Wesdyk of FDA's Office of Pharmaceutical Quality told the committee that FDA treats each salt, ester and free base as a distinct bulk drug substance. "When FDA places a BDS on the 503A Bulks List through rulemaking, and a salt or ester of an active moiety is listed, only that particular salt or ester may be used." This is why the July 2026 questions asked separately about, for example, "BPC-157 (free base)" and "BPC-157 acetate". It is also why FDA staff raised the problem of common or company names without an official United States Adopted Name: in Wesdyk's words, "it's not clear what is being nominated, compounded, or what substance patients are being dosed with."
How 503B is different
Outsourcing facilities registered under section 503B can make larger batches without patient-specific prescriptions, but they must follow good manufacturing practice and report adverse events. Their bulk ingredients come from a different list, the 503B "clinical need" list, or from drugs on FDA's shortage list. The 503B process runs through Federal Register notices rather than the PCAC route used for 503A. In May 2026 FDA used it to propose keeping semaglutide, tirzepatide and liraglutide off the 503B list.
From nomination to listing
- Someone nominates a substance, usually a pharmacy, a trade group or a clinic network.
- FDA's Office of Compounding Quality and Compliance, Office of New Drugs and Office of Pharmaceutical Quality review it against the four criteria.
- FDA presents its evaluation to the PCAC, which votes. The vote is advisory.
- FDA publishes a proposed rule, takes comments, and publishes a final rule. Only then is the substance on the list.
A nomination can be withdrawn at any point. FDA has chosen to present withdrawn nominations to the committee anyway: its December 2024 and July 2026 briefing documents both note that a nomination "was withdrawn by the nominator" and that "FDA is electing to proceed".
State boards of pharmacy remain the day-to-day regulators of 503A pharmacies. FDA's own slide put it plainly: compounded products "under 503A are primarily overseen by state regulators". The state laws page covers what states have done. For the words themselves, the compounded glossary entry is a short primer.
Rules change faster than most people's records. If you are on a prescribed peptide, the dose log keeps each dose with the product, the pharmacy and the concentration, and bloodwork sits on the same timeline, so a change of product or source is easier to plan with your prescriber. The peptide library grades how much research exists behind each compound, and that grading does not move when a committee votes. The app is on iOS and Android.
Questions people ask
What is the 503A bulks list?
It is a list, created by an FDA rule in February 2019, of bulk drug substances that a 503A compounding pharmacy may use even though they have no USP monograph and are not part of an approved drug. A substance is added only by notice-and-comment rulemaking.
Is any peptide on the 503A bulks list?
Not as of 15 October 2026. Six peptides were recommended by the advisory committee in July 2026, but FDA had not published a proposed rule to add them.
What is Category 1?
It is FDA's interim category for nominated substances still under evaluation. FDA does not generally intend to act against compounding from them in the meantime. GHK-Cu for non-injectable routes is in Category 1.
Does listing mean FDA approval?
No. FDA's own July 2026 presentation said a product compounded from a listed substance is not FDA approved, need not carry directions for use, and need not be reported to FDA when adverse events occur.
Why does FDA vote on the free base and the acetate separately?
FDA treats each salt, ester and free base as a distinct bulk drug substance. If only one form is listed, only that form may be used.
Sources
- List of bulk drug substances that can be used to compound drug products under section 503A (84 FR 4696), Federal Register, 19 February 2019
- Amendments to the list of bulk drug substances under section 503A, proposed rule (84 FR 46688), Federal Register, 5 September 2019
- Interim policy on compounding using bulk drug substances under section 503A; final guidance (90 FR 1136), Federal Register, 7 January 2025
- Bulk drug substances nominated for use in compounding under section 503A (categories 1, 2 and 3), U.S. Food and Drug Administration, updated 14 May 2026
- FDA Briefing Document, introduction, PCAC meeting July 23-24, 2026, U.S. Food and Drug Administration
- FDA presentations, PCAC meeting, July 23, 2026, U.S. Food and Drug Administration
- Questions for the Committee, July 23-24, 2026, U.S. Food and Drug Administration
- FDA Briefing Document, PCAC meeting December 4, 2024, U.S. Food and Drug Administration
- List of bulk drug substances for which there is a clinical need under section 503B (91 FR 23431), Federal Register, 1 May 2026
